Haredi Jews Prioritize Rabbinic Over Medical Advice, Study Finds


In an illuminating exploration of Haredi Jews’ approach to healthcare, researchers Rivka Neriya‐Ben Shahar, Fany Yuval, and Aviad Tur‐Sinai shed light on the complex interplay between religious authority and medical advice. Their study, published in the Journal of Religion and Health, reveals how Haredi communities in Israel often turn to rabbis as the ultimate decision-makers in health-related matters, even when their guidance conflicts with that of medical professionals.

Study Methodology and Findings

The researchers gathered insights through 16 focus groups, engaging 128 Haredi participants from key Israeli communities. The study aimed to understand the dynamics between patients, doctors, and rabbis within the ultra-Orthodox Jewish community. Findings suggest a profound loyalty to rabbinic authority, with participants indicating that in cases of disagreement between a doctor and a rabbi, the latter’s word is usually taken as final. This deference to religious leaders over health practitioners underscores the significance of spiritual guidance in the Haredi community, even at the expense of personal health.

Rabbinic Influence on Medical Decisions

Participants shared various anecdotes reflecting the nuanced relationship between faith and healthcare. For instance, some rabbis may advise seeking treatment at more advanced medical facilities, regardless of religious observances such as Shabbat, while others might prioritize adherence to religious laws over receiving the highest standard of medical care. This variance highlights the diverse perspectives within the Haredi community itself. Additionally, the study points out the community’s desire for healthcare professionals to better understand and respect their religious values and practices.

Community Dynamics and Healthcare Accessibility

The concept of ‘self-sacrifice’ emerged as a recurring theme, with community members willing to compromise on health decisions to maintain their standing within the ultra-Orthodox society. The researchers also discuss the existence of a ‘market’ for rabbinic advice, where those with more ‘capital’ – in terms of social or financial standing – can navigate these decisions with greater flexibility. Such dynamics reveal the complex factors influencing healthcare choices among Haredi Jews, extending beyond mere religious adherence to include social and economic considerations.

As this study illuminates, the relationship between Haredi Jews, their rabbis, and medical professionals is multifaceted, rooted in a deep commitment to faith that often transcends conventional medical wisdom. While this allegiance to religious authority may pose challenges, it also speaks to the strength and cohesion of the Haredi community, even in the face of health crises. As healthcare systems continue to evolve, understanding and respecting these religious considerations will be crucial in ensuring that all communities receive care that aligns with their beliefs and values.





Source link

Back To Top